Skip to main content
  • Old School NY Pizza - Norton Commons logo top - Homepage
    Old School NY Pizza - Norton Commons logo scroll - Homepage
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Locations
  • Google page
Old School NY Pizza - Norton Commons logo top - HomepageOld School NY Pizza - Norton Commons logo scroll - Homepage
  • Google page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Locations

Our Menu

  • Menu

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs, may increase your risk of food-borne illness.

Pizza Pies

Cheese

$13.50/+
Tomato sauce topped with Italian herbs, spices, mozzarella, and romano cheese | 12" $13.50 | 18" $22.00

Veggie

$18.25/+
Tomato sauce topped with Italian herbs, spices, mushroom, green peppers, onions, black olives, roasted garlic, tomato, garlic oil, mozzarella and romano cheese | 12" $18.25 | 18" $30.00

Whitestone

$15.25/+
Ricotta spread topped with Italian herbs, spices, mozzarella, romano, and garlic oil | 12" $15.25 | 18" $25.00

Hawaiian

$18.00/+
Tomato sauce topped with ham, pineapple, bacon, mozzarella, romano, and cheddar cheese | 12" $18.00 | 18" $29.50

Tomato Basil

$17.50/+
Fresh basil topped with Italian herbs, spices, mozzarella, romano, tomato and garlic oil | 12" $17.50| 18" $28.50

Ford / UAWKY Truck Plant Pie

$18.00/+
Chicken, bacon, ranch, banana peppers and mozzarella cheese | 12" $18.00 | 18" $29.50

Porko

$19.00/+
Tomato sauce topped with Italian herbs, spices, pepperoni, Italian sausage, meatballs, mozzarella and romano cheese | 12" $19.00 | 18" $31.00

All Meat

$19.00/+
Tomato sauce topped with Italian herbs, spices, pepperoni, Italian sausage, Halal beef, bacon, cheddar, mozzarella and romano cheese | 12" $19.00 | 18" $31.00

PBR (Potato, Bacon & Ranch)

$18.00/+
Roasted Garlic Spread, topped with Italian herbs, spices, rosemary, potato, bacon, mozzarella, romano, cheddar and a drizzle of ranch dressing | 12" $18.00 | 18" $29.50

Brooklyn Deluxe

$20.75/+
Tomato sauce topped with Italian herbs, spices, mushroom, green peppers, onions, black olives, roasted garlic, Italian sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella and romano cheese | 12" $20.75 | 18" $34.00

Bacon, Cheddar & Jalapeño

$18.00/+
Tomato sauce topped with Italian herbs, spices, bacon, jalapeño, mozzarella and cheddar cheese | 12" $18.00 | 18" $29.50

BBQ or Buffalo Chicken

$18.00/+
All white meat chicken topped with BBQ (or Buffalo) sauce, mozzarella, bacon and ranch dressing | 12" $18.00 | 18" $29.50

Philly Cheesesteak

$22.25/+
Tomato sauce topped with Italian herbs and spices, steak, white American and mozzarella | 12" $22.25 | 18" $36.50

Chicken Pesto

$18.00
Nut-free pesto sauce with grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, mozzarella, romano, and shaved parmesan cheese | 12" $18.00 | 18" $29.50

Lasagna Pizza

$18.00
Ricotta spread topped with Italian herbs, spices, mozzarella, romano cheese, meatballs and dollops of pizza sauce | 12" $18.00 | 18" $29.50

Create Your Own

Cheese Pizza

$13.50/+
12" 13.50 | 18" $22.00

EXTRA TOPPING OPTIONS:

12" | 18"

Sauces

Tomato Sauce $0.85, $1.70 | BBQ Sauce $0.85, $1.70 | Buffalo Sauce $0.85, $1.70 | Ranch Dressing $0.85, $1.70 | Alfredo Sauce $0.85, $1.70 | Pesto $0.85, $1.70| Mike's Hot Honey (as a topping) $0.85, $1.70 | Ricotta Spread $1.65, $3.30 | Roasted Garlic Spread $1.65, $3.30

Veggies

Tomatoes $1.65, $3.30 | Onions $1.65, $3.30 | Mushrooms $1.65, $3.30 | Fresh Cooked Spinach $1.65, $3.30 | Green Peppers $1.65, $3.30 | Roasted Garlic $1.65, $3.30 | Pineapple $1.65, $3.30 | Banana Peppers $1.65, $3.30 | Fresh Jalapeños $1.65, $3.30 | Roasted Red Peppers $1.65, $3.30 | Olives (Green, Black or Kalamata) $1.65, $3.30 | Basil $1.65, $3.30 | Potatoes $1.65, $3.30

Cheeses

Mozzarella $1.65, $3.30 | Cheddar $1.65, $3.30 | Ricotta $1.65, $3.30 | Feta $1.65, $3.30 | Romano $1.65, $3.30 | Shaved Parmesan $1.65, $3.30

Meats

Pepperoni $1.65, $3.30 | Italian Sausage $1.65, $3.30 | Meatballs $1.65, $3.30 | Ham $1.65, $3.30 | Bacon $1.65, $3.30 | Chicken $1.65, $3.30 | Halal Beef $1.65, $3.30 | Spicy Chicken Sausage $1.65, $3.30 | Steak $7.50, $15.00

Pasta

All pasta served with garlic bread.

Spaghetti with Marinara

$10.00
Add (2) Meatballs for $2.50 | Add Mozzarella cheese for $1.00

Kids Spaghetti with Marinara

$6.00
Add (1) Meatballs for$1.50 | Add Mozzarella cheese for $.75

Chicken Alfredo

$12.00
Fettucine pasta with alfredo sauce and chicken - $10 without Chicken

Kids Chicken Alfredo

$8.00
Fettucine pasta with alfredo sauce and chicken - $6 without Chicken

Handhelds

Add fries and a fountain drink for $5

Meatball Parm Sub

$13.00
Meatballs (4), tomato sauce, mozzarella and parmesan cheese on freshly baked 8" bread

Italian Grinder

$13.00
Pepperoni, ham, salami and provolone on freshly baked 8" bread, toasted. Comes with mayo, lettuce, tomato, red onion and creamy Italian dressing

Philly Sub

$13.00
Choose Cheese: Provolone or White American | Choose Protein: Steak or Chicken | Choose Toppings (add $.85 each): Lettuce, tomatoes, grilled onions, grilled mushrooms, grilled green peppers, grilled banana peppers, fresh jalapeños

Chicken Parmesan Sub

$13.00
Fried chicken tenders, tomato sauce, mozzarella and parmesan cheeses on freshly baked 8" bread

Fried Chicken Sub

$13.00
Served with lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on freshly baked 8" bread. Your choice of Chicken tossed in Buffalo, BBQ, or No sauce

Hot Italian Beef Sub

$13.00
Tender Italian beef dipped in au jus, topped with white American cheese and served on freshly baked 8" Italian bread, toasted. Served with a side of au jus

Veggie Sub

$12.00
Choice of any 4 vegetables listed in pizza section plus romaine lettuce, served on freshly baked 8" Italian bread. Served hot or cold with choice of cheese.

Calzones

Calzone

$13.00
Mozzarella, ricotta, and romano cheese served with marinara on the side | Extra toppings available for... 1.65 each

Salads

Add grilled or fried chicken to any salad: Small $3.85 | Large $6.50 | Dressings: House Vinaigrette, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Caesar, Blue Cheese, House Thousand Island, Ranch and Fat-Free Ranch (Each additional sauce... add $.85)

Garden Salad

$7.50/+
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, cucumbers, red onions, mozzarella cheese and croutons | Small $7.50 | Large $14.50

Caesar Salad

$7.50/+
Caesar Romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan and croutons | Small $7.50 | Large $13.00

Greek Salad

$8.75/+
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, cucumbers, red onions, kalamata olives, feta cheese and croutons | Small $8.75 | Large $16.00

Sides

Sauces: BBQ, Buffalo (mild or hot), Garlic Parmesan, Mango Jalapeno, Nashville Hot BBQ, Honey Mustard, and Marinara (Each additional sauce... add $.85) Add $2 for Mike's Hot Honey side cup

Garlic Knots

$8.00
Freshly baked, smothered with garlic butter and parmesan cheese served with marinara

Pepperoni Knots

$9.00
Freshly baked with pepperoni, smothered with garlic butter and parmesan cheese, and served with marinara sauce

Mozzarella Sticks (6)

$7.50
Served with marinara sauce

Cheesy Bread

$14.00
Freshly baked cheesy bread with a garlic spread and a side of marinara sauce

Fried Ravioli

$7.50
Beef ravioli served with marinara sauce

Chicken Tenders

$5.00/+
2 for $5 | 4 for $9

Bone-in Wings (8)

$14.50
Choose Buffalo, Hot or Mild, BBQ, or Garlic parmesan, Mango Jalapeno, Nashville Hot BBQ | Celery Sticks... $0.75

Meatballs (4)

$9.75
Served with marinara and provolone cheese | (Served with only marinara... $9.25)

French Fries

$3.75
Add cheese for $1

Onion Rings

$4.75

Chips

$1.70

Mac & Cheese Wedges

$7.50
Served with Buffalo Ranch Sauce on the side

Jalapeno Cheddar Bites

$7.50
Served with Ranch dressing on the side

Sweets

Brownie

$2.25

Cannolis (3)

$8.00

Cinnamon Knots

$8.50

Vanilla Ice Cream

$3.00

Ice Cream Sundae

$5.00
Vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream and cherry

Hot Fudge Ice Cream Brownie Sundae

$7.00
Vanilla ice cream, brownie, hot fudge, whipped cream and cherry
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering